Moving towards a Normalised Path: Political Islam in Contemporary Indonesia

Authors

  • RIDHO AL-HAMDI Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18196/jgp.8150

Keywords:

Islam-based parties, democratisation, normalisation, Indonesia

Abstract

As the largest predominantly Muslim country of the globe, Indonesia nearly achieves two decades of its democratisation wave since the downfall of the Au- thoritarian Rule in 1998. Political parties, one of the crucial democratic institutions, have a signifi- cant responsibility to maintain the democratic system as they are the sole official representatives to create leaders and policies in the government. This paper portrays the trajectory of political Islam in Indonesia particularly Islam-based parties slightly under two decades since Post- New Order regime. Islam-based parties have a potential to be a moderate-offi- cial force in the government. It could be proven by the threefold indicator. First is the ripeness of Islam-based parties in coping with both internal and external stimuli such as the leadership change and elite conflicts, the constitutional re- form and the electoral result. Second is the role of Muslim political forces in the parliament particularly in addressing the policy making of controversial bills. Third is the involvement of Islam-based parties in the administration cabinet. To sum up, by applying the analytical framework on the party goal, political Islam in Indonesia has three distinctive features: As “the vote-seekers” in the election, as “the issue-advocates” in the legislature and as “the office-seekers” in the execu- tive. These denote to a normalised path of political Islam in reaching out the embedded democracy.

References

Abdulbaki, Louay.(2008).Democratization and Islamic political activism in Muslim-major-

ity countries: Egypt and Indonesia. PhD Dissertation, TheUniversity of Melbourne

Abuza, Zachary. (2007). Political Islam and violence in Indonesia. London and New York:

Routledge

Al-Hamdi, Ridho. (2013). Partai politik Islam: Teori dan praktik di Indonesia. Yogyakarta:

Graha Ilmu

Ambardi, Kuskridho. (2008). The making ofthe Indonesian multiparty system: A cartelized

party systemand its origin. PhD Dissertation, TheOhioState University

Aspinall, Edward. (2010). “Indonesia in 2009: Democratic triumphs and trials”, South-

east Asian Affairs, Vol. 2010, pp. 103-125

Aspinall, Edward. (2013). “How Indonesia survived: Comparative perspectives on state

disintegrationanddemocratic integration”,inMirjamKünklerandAlfred Stepan(Eds.),

Democracy and Islam in Indonesia.NewYork:Columbia University Press

Badan Pekerja MPR, Sekretariat Jenderal. (2000). Catatan hasil rapat amandemen UUD

Buku II, Jilid 3. Jakarta

Barton, Greg. (2006). “Islam and democratic transition in Indonesia”, in Tun-Jen Cheng and Deborah A. Brown (Eds.), Religious organizations and democratization: Case

studies from contemporary Asia. London: Armonk

Baswedan, Anis Rasyid. (2004). “Political Islam in Indonesia: Present and future trajec-

tory ”, Asian Survey, Vol. 44, No. 5, pp. 669-690

Buehler, Michael. (2009). “Islam and democracy in Indonesia”, Insight Turkey, Vol. 11,

No. 4, pp. 51-63

Bush, Robin. (2009). Nahdlatul Ulama and the struggle for power within Islam and poli-

tics in Indonesia. Singapore: ISEAS

Bünte, Marco and Andreas Ufen. (2009). “The New Order and its legacy reflections on

democratization in Indonesia”, in Marco Bünte and Andreas Ufen (Eds.), Democrati-

zation in post-Suharto Indonesia. London and New York: Routledge

Carnegie, PaulJ.(2014). “IsIndonesia’s democratization a roadmap fortheArab Spring?”,

Journal of Diplomacy and International Relations, Vol. 5, No. 1 (Fall/Winter), pp. 95-

Dahl, Robert A. (1972). Polyarchy: Participation and opposition. New Haven: Yale Univer-

sityPress

Damanik, Ali Said. (2002). Fenomena Partai Keadilan: Transformasi 20 tahun gerakan

Tarbiyah di Indonesia. Jakarta: Teraju

Deschouwer, Kris. (1992). “The survival of the fittest: Measuring and explaining adapta-

tion and change of political parties”, paper prepared for presentation at the Work-

shop on Democracies and the organization of political parties, European Consortium

for Political Research, Limerick, Ireland, 30 March–4 April

Downs, Anthony. (1957). An economic theory of democracy. New York: Harper and Row

Eldersveld, SamuelJ.(1964).Politicalparties:Abehavioralanalysis.Chicago:RandMcNally

Evans, Kevin Raymond. (2003). The history of political parties and general elections in

Indonesia. Jakarta: Arise Consultancies

Feith, Herbert. (1957). The Indonesian election of 1955. New York: Cornell University

Ithaca

Feith, Herbert.(1962). Thedeclineofconstitutionaldemocracyin Indonesia. Ithaca: Cornell

University Press

Fionna, Ulla.(2013). The institutionalisation of political partiesin post-authoritarian Indo-

nesia: From the grass-roots up.Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press

Freedom House. (2014). “Freedom in the world 2014: Annual report” at

www.freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-world/freedom-world-2014

Hadiwinata, Bob S. and Christoph Schuck. (2007). “Mapping Indonesia’s way towards

democracy: In search of a theoretical frame”, in Bob S. Hadiwinata/Cristoph Schuck

(Eds.), Democracy in Indonesia: The challenge of consolidation. Baden-Baden: No-

mos-Verlag

Hadiz, Vedi R. (2011). “No Turkish delight: The impasse of Islamic party politicsin Indone-

sia”, Indonesia Journal, Vol. 92 (October), pp. 1-18

Hamayotsu, Kikue. (2011a). “The end of political Islam? A comparative analysis of reli-

gious parties in the Muslim democracy of Indonesia ”, Journal of Current Southeast

Asian Affairs, Vol. 30, No. 3, pp. 133-159

Hamayotsu, Kikue. (2011b). ‘‘The rise of the Prosperous Justice Party in post-authoritar-

ian Indonesia: Examining the political economy of Islamist mobilization in a Muslim

democracy”, Asian Survey, Vol. 51, No. 5, pp. 971-992

Harmel, Robert and Kenneth Janda. (1994). “An integrated theory of party goals and

party change”, Journal of Theoretical Politics, Vol. 06, No. 03, pp. 259-287

Hassan,Noorhaidi.(2009).‘‘Islamistparty,electoralpolitics,andDa’wamobilizationamong

youth: The Prosperous Justice Party”, RSIS Working Paper (22 October), pp. 1-27

Hefner,RobertW.(2000).CivilIslam:MuslimsanddemocratizationinIndonesia.Princeton

and Oxford: Princeton University Press

Hefner, Robert W. (2009a). “Introduction: Modernity and the remaking of Muslim poli-

tics”, in Robert W. Hefner (Ed.), Remaking Muslim politics: Pluralism, contestation,

democratization. Princeton an Oxford: Princeton University Press

Hefner, Robert W. (2009b). “Muslim democrats and Islamist violence in post-Soeharto

Indonesia”, in Robert W.Hefner (Ed.), Remaking Muslim politics: Pluralism, contesta-

tion,democratization.PrincetonanOxford:PrincetonUniversityPress

Hidayat, Syahrul. (2012). Managing moderation: The AKP in Turkey and the PKS in Indo-

nesia. PhD Dissertation, University of Exeter

Hilmy, Masdar. (2010). Islamism and democracy in Indonesia: Piety and pragmatism.

Singapore: ISEAS

Hosen,Nadirsyah.(2007). Sharia and constitutionalreformin Indonesia.Singapore:ISEAS

Huntington, Samuel P. (1991). The third wave: Democratization in the late twentieth

century. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press

Hwang, Julie Chernov. (2014). “Patterns of normalization: Islamist parties in Indonesia”,

in Quinn Mecham and Julie Chernov Hwang (Eds.), Islamist parties and political nor-

malization intheMuslimworld.Philadelphia:UniversityofPennsylvaniaPress

King, Dwight Y. (2003). Half-hearted reform: Electoral institutions and the struggle for

democracy in Indonesia. Westport and Connecticut: Praeger

Lee,Jeff.(2004). “ThefailureofpoliticalIslamin Indonesia:A historical narrative”, Standford

Journal of East Asian Affairs, Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 85-104

Liddle, R. William. (2013). “Improving the quality of democracy in Indonesia: Toward a

theory of action”, Indonesia, No. 96, Special Issue: Wealth, Power, and Contempo-

rary Indonesian Politics (October), pp. 59-80

Liddle, R. William and Saiful Mujani. (2013). “Indonesian democracy: From transition to

consolidation”, in Mirjam Künkler and Alfred Stepan (Eds.), Democracy and Islam in

Indonesia. New York: Columbia University Press

Machmudi, Yon. (2006). Islamizing Indonesia. The rise of Jemaah Tarbiyah and the Pros-

perous Justice Party. PhD Dissertation, Australian National University

Magnis-Suseno, Franz. (2013). “Indonesia’s challenge: Making democracy succeded”, in

Matthias Heise and Kathrin Rucktäschel (Eds.), Indonesia’s search for democracy:

Political, economic, and social developments. Baden-Baden: Nomos-Verlag

Mainwaring, Scott. (1991). “Politicians, parties, and electoral systems: Brazil in compara-

tive perspective”, Comparative Politics, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 21-43

Maor, Moshe. (1997). Political parties and party systems: Comparative approaches and

the British experience. London: Routledge

Mecham, Quinn and Julie Chernov Hwang. (2014). “Introduction: The emergence and

development ofIslamist political parties”, inQuinn MechamandJulieChernovHwang

(Eds.), Islamist parties and political normalization in the Muslim world. Philadelphia:

University of Pennsylvania Press

Merkel, Wolfgang.(2007). “Embedded and defective democracies”, in BobS.Hadiwinata/

CristophSchuck (Eds.),Democracy in Indonesia: The challenge of consolidation.Baden-

Baden: Nomos-Verlag

Merkel, Wolfgang and Aurel Croissant. (2004). “Conclusion: Good and defective democ-

racies”, Democratization, Vol. 11, No. 5, pp. 199-213

Michels, Robert. (1915). Political parties. London: Jarrold

Mietzner, Marcus. (2009). “Indonesia and the pitfalls of low-quality democracy: A case

study of the gubernatorial elections in North Sulawesi”, in Marco Bünte and Andreas

Ufen (Eds.), Democratization in post-Suharto Indonesia. London and New York:

Routledge

Mietzner, Marcus. (2014). “How Jokowi won and democracy survived”, Journal of De-

mocracy, Vol. 25, No. 4, pp. 111-125

Mujani, Saiful and R. William Liddle. (2009). “Muslim Indonesia’s secular democracy”, Asian Survey, Vol. 49, Issue 4, pp. 575–590

Mustarom, Tuti Raihanah and V. Arianti. (2009). “Declining support for Islamist parties:

Exploring the Indonesian ‘paradox’”, RSIS Commentaries, 5 May, pp. 1-3

Nasr, Vali. (2005). “The rise of Muslim democracy”, Journal of Democracy, Vol. 16, No. 2,

pp. 13-27

Neumann, Sigmund. (1963). “Toward a comparative study of political parties”, in Harry

Eckstein and David E. Apter (Eds.), Comparative politics: A reader.New York:The Free

Press

Noor, Firman. (2012). Institutionalising Islamic political parties in Indonesia: A study of

internal fragmentation and cohesion in the post-Soeharto era (1998-2008). PhD Dis-

sertation, University of Exeter

Nurdin, Ahmad Ali. (2009). Islamic political parties and democracy: A comparative study

of PKS in Indonesia and PAS in Malaysia (1998-2005). PhD Dissertation, National

UniversityofSingapore

Ostrogorski, Moisei. (1902). Democracy and the organization of political parties. London:

Macmillan

Permata, Ahmad-Norma. (2008). Islamist party and democratic participation: Prosperous

Justice Party (PKS) in Indonesia 1998-2006. PhD Dissertation, der Westfälischen

Wilhelms-Universität zu Münster

Platzdach, Bernard. (2009). Islamism in Indonesia: Politics in the emerging democracy.

Singapore: ISEAS

Press Release PKS on “Penjelasan DPP PKS tentang kenaikan BBM”, 22 March 2005

Priamarizki, Adhi. (2013). “Indonesia’s national elections: Islamic parties at the cross-

roads”, RSIS Commentaries, No. 005 (9 January), pp. 1-2

Price, David E. (1984). Bringing back the parties. Washington DC: Congressional Quar-

terly Press

Ramage, Douglas E. (2007). “Indonesia: Democracy first, good governance later”, South-

east Asian Affairs, Vol. 2007, No. 1, pp. 135-157

Randall, Vicky. (1988). Political parties in the third world. London: Sage

Risalah Resmi Rapat Paripurna DPR RI Ke-15 Masa Sidang II Tahun 2009-2010, 2 March

Salim, Arskal. (1999). Partai Islam dan relasi agama-negara. Jakarta: Kerjasama Puslit IAIN

Syarif Hidayatullah dengan the Asia Fondation dan JPPR

Sartori,Giovanni.(1976).Parties and party systems:Aframework for analysis.Cambridge:

Cambridge University Press

Scarrow, Susan E. (2006). “The nineteenth-century origins of modern political parties:

The unwanted emergence of party-based politics”, in Richard S. Katz and William

Crotty, Handbook of party politics. London: SAGE Publication

Schumpeter, Joseph A. (2008). Capitalism, socialism, and democracy. Third Edition. New

York:Harper Perennial

Strom, Kaare. (1990). “A behavioral theory of competitive political parties”, American

Journal of Political Science, Vol. 34, Issue 2 (May), pp. 565-598

Sukmajati, Mada. (2011). How Islamic parties organize at the local level in post-Suharto

Indonesia: An empirical study of six major Islamic parties in the Tasikmalaya District,

WestJavaProvince.PhDDissertation,derRuprecht-Karls-UniversitätHeidelberg

Sumarjan, Joni, et al. (2002). Tinjauan kritis respon parlemen terhadap masalah Piagam

Jakarta:Debatpenerapan syariatIslam.Jakarta: INSIDE

Tanuwidjaja, Sunny. (2010). “Political Islam and Islamic parties in Indonesia: Critically as-

sessing the evidence of Islam’s political decline”, Contemporary Southeast Asia, Vol.

, No. 1, pp. 29-49

Ufen, Andreas. (2008). “Political party and party system institutionalization in Southeast

Asia: Lessons for democratic consolidation in Indonesia, the Philippines and Thai-land”, The Pacific Review, Vol. 21, No. 3 (July), pp. 327-350

Ufen, Andreas. (2009). “Political parties and democratization in Indonesia”, in Marco

Bünte and Andreas Ufen (Eds.), Democratization in post-Suharto Indonesia. London

and New York: Routledge

Webber, Douglas. (2007). “A consolidated patrimonial democracy? Democratization in

post-Suharto Indonesia,” in Frédéric Volpi and Francesco Cavatorta (Eds.), Democra-

tization in the Muslim world: Changing patterns of power and authority. London:

Routledge

Winters, Jeffrey A. (2013). “Oligarchy and democracy in Indonesia”, Indonesia, No. 96,

Special Issue: Wealth, power, and contemporary Indonesian politics (October), pp.

-33

Woischnik, Jan and Philipp Müller. (2013). “Islamic parties and democracy in Indonesia:

Insights from the world’s largest Muslim country”, International Reports (14 Octo-

ber), pp. 59-79

Yildirim, Abdulkadir. (2010). Muslim democratic parties: Economic liberalization and Is-

lamist moderation in the Middle East. PhD Dissertation, The Ohio State University

Websites

www.balipost.co.id

www.bulan-bintang.org

www.detik.com

www.dpp-pkb.or.id

www.kpu.go.id

www.pan.or.id

www.ppp.or.id

www.suaramerdeka.com

www.viva.co.id

Downloads

Published

2023-04-04